Beyond the Blade: How Hypnosis Can Reshape Your Pain

As a hand surgeon, I have spent my career using my hands to help others — repairing tendons, reconstructing joints, restoring function. But an unusual diagnosis sparked an interest in hypnosis, and it has quietly transformed how I treat one of the most common problems in my patients.

“The nervous system doesn’t always distinguish between what is happening and what it believes is happening. Hypnosis works in that space.”

Aaron Grand, m.d.

What Hypnosis Actually Is — and Isn’t

Let’s start with what hypnosis is not: it is not sleep, unconsciousness, or the theatrical spectacle of a stage performer making volunteers cluck like chickens. Clinical hypnosis is a focused, evidence-based therapeutic state — a heightened mode of attention in which the critical, analytical mind becomes quieter, and the subconscious becomes more receptive to suggestion and reframing.

Every patient who enters hypnosis does so voluntarily. Patients remain comfortable, aware, in control, and able to exit the state at any time. What changes is the ability to access the subconscious and neurological patterns that affect our habits, behaviors, and even our perception of pain.

Chronic Thumb Pain: When Surgery Has Done Its Job

Thumb pain — particularly due to arthritis at the carpometacarpal (CMC) joint — is extremely common and affects most adults over the age of 65 to some extent. Conservative management works well for many people, and corticosteroid injections can provide relief for many others. When these treatments are no longer helpful, I have recommended surgery. There are well-established surgical procedures, which can result in restoration of a functional, pain-free thumb. Most patients do beautifully.

But a small subset does not. Their scars heal beautifully, their therapy is complete — and yet they report persistent pain, hypersensitivity to touch, or weakness. Other patients are poor surgical candidates, due to other medical conditions. And some are just too nervous about having surgery.

This is where hypnotherapy becomes a powerful tool.

What a session looks like

In a typical session for arthritic thumb pain, I guide the patient into a relaxed hypnotic state and then use metaphors and suggestion to alter the way the brain interprets signals from that area of the hand. Each patient’s experience is unique — some imagine a cooling sensation spreading through the thumb, others change the intensity or the character of the sensation, and still others visualize the joint moving freely and comfortably. The subconscious mind can determine what changes need to occur.

Chronic thumb pain is often also associated with a fear of re-injury, protective guarding, and identity around the injury. These are not imaginary problems — they are encoded in the nervous system and can also respond to hypnotic intervention.

The Neuroscience

Neuroimaging studies have shown that hypnosis produces measurable changes in brain activity — particularly in the anterior cingulate cortex and prefrontal regions, which are involved in pain processing and executive control. Hypnotic analgesia is not placebo; it actually alters the way pain signals are processed and interpreted.

For chronic pain in particular, hypnosis can interrupt the central sensitization loop — the process by which the nervous system becomes "tuned up" for pain even after the original tissue injury has resolved.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can everyone be hypnotized?

Most people can enter a useful hypnotic state — studies suggest roughly 80–85% of the population is hypnotizable to a meaningful degree. People who “couldn’t be hypnotized before” often respond well to a different technique for hypnotic induction. A small group is relatively resistant. For the most part, anyone who really wants to be hypnotized, can be hypnotized by a well-trained hypnotherapist.  

Is hypnosis safe? Will I say or do something I don't want to?

Clinical hypnosis is safe and well-tolerated. You remain conscious and in control throughout the session — you cannot be made to do or say anything against your values or wishes. The hypnotic state is similar to deep absorption in a book or film: focused, relaxed, but aware. All sessions are conducted in a clinical setting with full informed consent.

How many sessions does it take?

It varies by condition and individual. Management of chronic thumb pain may require three to four sessions, but most of my patients experience a marked improvement after the first session and do not feel the need to have additional sessions.

Is this instead of surgery or medication — or alongside it?

It depends on the situation. I always evaluate each patient individually and recommend the approach most likely to help them specifically. Generally, I recommend standard conservative management of thumb arthritis pain.  But when patients do not get adequate relief and surgery would be the next step, hypnotherapy can be an amazing and effective option. 

Why haven’t I heard about this before?

My background in hand surgery combined with my hypnosis training gives me a unique perspective on this common problem and therefore allows me to provide a treatment option that other hand surgeons cannot.

Can you take care of other problems at the same time?

Maybe!  Many patients find that the subconscious changes that happen during treatment for thumb arthritis carry over to other areas of their life.

Curious whether hypnotherapy is right for you?

Dr. Grand offers consultations at the Hand and Shoulder Center for patients dealing with chronic thumb pain.

Don't know where to start?

Request an appointment with us to determine how to help you be pain-free.